I’m a phenomenal baker.
I say that laughing to myself because on HGTV’s show “Design Star” last night the same guy who professed to being a “phenomenal muralist” got kicked off for designing a crappy mural… but I digress. I’m a competent baker. I love to bake, people eat my baked goods, and I’ve done a lot of baking and so I’m pretty good at figuring out why things turn out great or not so great. I’m not going to sit here and regurgitate recipes to you, they are already written down elsewhere. What I am going to do is give you some of my step-by-step pictures and the little tweaks I made along the way. Hopefully you will gain some confidence after seeing my experience to try it out yourself!
The recipe: Lemon Ricotta Cookies
This recipe was sent to me by E during her pregnancy and I finally got around to making them for the first time a couple months ago (by the time I got to it E’s son was old enough to eat cookies. I know I’m so on top of things). The first time I made these they were AMAZING. Light, fluffy, lemony- a perfect cool light cookie for a summer party.
So, I started this time by assembling my ingredients. A few notes:
1) The recipe calls for unsalted butter- I happen to have it, but if I didn’t I would have used salted and left the salt out of the recipe. But, if you bake a lot buy some unsalted butter. Butter freezes well, so keep it in the freezer until you need it.
2) Always use “whole milk” dairy products in baking, lower fat products have too much water and will mess you up,

All the stuff you need to make cookie magic
Alright, time to get started!
Step 1 Putting the dry stuff together- easy peasey.

Flour, baking soda, etc.
Step 2 In the mixing bowl- combine butter and sugar until fluffy.
AH! Let’s talk about sugar. This recipe calls for 2 cups but that seems like a ton to me. So I cut my sugar to 1.25 cups. Don’t worry, at the end you drench the cookies in a glaze (more sugar). Trust me, cutting the sugar actually makes these cookies better.

Not a ton of sugar.
Step 3 Add the eggs. My eggs are brown because I know a guy with a chicken. White eggs work exactly the same.
Step 4 Dealing with the lemon. Okay, because I got married two years ago and people like to give you funny things for your wedding I do happen to own a lemon zester, and it did come in handy here. However, since I really hope most people don’t have a zester, you can do this with a regular cheese grater, or even with a knife. The point is to GENTLY scrape the lemon until you see white (usually one scrape, two at most), then move on to a different area of a lemon. Once your lemon looks all zestless, roll it on the counter to loosen the juices and cut it open. This recipe takes pretty much all the juice from the lemon, I wouldn’t bother measuring 3 tablespoons. Unless your lemon is soccer ball sized or something…

Zesty, no?
Step 5 Mix it all up….then stir in the dry ingredients.

Dough, boy!
Bada bing- you got yer dough.
A note on baking surfaces: I do not own wonderful baking sheets. I have yet to find wonderful baking sheets even though I have tried (I’m not spending $50 on a baking sheet). As a result, I do all my baking on pizza stones. Pros: even baking, near impossible to burn. Cons: heavy, smaller. If you have a tendency to burn things I urge you to pick up a pizza stone and try one out. I got mine for scones (which are my favorite thing to bake) and now I just use them for everything. Also- I always bake on parchment paper. It too helps with the evenness.

This is a pizza stone. You don’t wash a pizza stone, just scrape and wipe clean after each use. Added bonus.
Step 6 Where I messed up.
This is the step where you take two spoons and scoop the dough onto the stone or baking sheet. I got a little antsy and scooped mine way too big (see below). They probably should have been half that size. Scooping the cookies too big wasn’t a horrible error, people would still like these cookies, but they did end up a bit heavier (the oven temp and cook time were not right for this size of cookie). The first time I made this recipe I made the cookies smaller and they were perfect, so I say stick to small cookies… dollops of dough about the size of a tealight candle.

THESE COOKIES ARE TOO BIG.

Yum, cookies.
Final Step
The last thing you do in this recipe is combine powdered sugar and lemon juice and glaze the cookies. I did that the first time and it was delicious, but I skipped it this time because my cookies had turned out more like biscuits. If this happens to you my suggestion is to slice the cookie in half and fill it with strawberries and whipped cream (like a lemon strawberry shortcake).
Lessons Learned: Keep it small, stupid. Big cookies are so hard to get the bake time right on. My goal with future cookies is to keep them small and even in size.
If you try this recipe, let me know what you think!